About Us

WILLIAMS, MOLITERNO & SCULLY CO., L.P.A., is an AV-rated law firm concentrating on civil trial practice. We are experienced trial lawyers with a proven record at the courthouse. Our uncompromising commitment to client service is the founding principle for everything we do.

The lawyers at Williams, Moliterno & Scully Co., L.P.A. blend their diverse talents to handle a wide range of civil litigation. The firm has an active insurance defense practice, wherein it represents virtually every major property and casualty insurance carrier in the country. We also represent several self-insured corporations such as Toys “R” Us, and Giant Eagle, Inc. In addition, our lawyers actively represent businesses and individuals in various civil trial matters.

The firm also handles a large volume of appellate work. This includes evaluating and litigating appeals, preparing post trial motions, as well as briefing and arguing before various Courts of Appeals in Ohio. Several members of our firm have appeared before the Ohio Supreme Court.

We have maintained the firm at a very manageable size so that we do not lose our ability to represent all of our clients, with an emphasis on individual attention.  We recognize the need to provide high quality legal representation in an environment which recognizes efficient billing practices without sacrificing that quality representation.  We welcome the opportunity to be of service to you.

Our litigation philosophy is simple. The client, after consultation with the firm, chooses the lawyer in the firm best suited to handle each individual case. We investigate and evaluate cases rapidly and accurately. We attempt to resolve cases on a fair and equitable basis, as soon as possible, with minimal expense to our clients. We are not just litigators, but truly trial lawyers. If a fair and equitable settlement cannot be reached, we are ready, willing and able to take a matter to trial. Though we cannot guarantee a win in every case, we do guarantee that our clients will be provided with the best representation available.

Significantly, Williams, Moliterno & Scully Co., L.P.A. has been certified by Martindale-Hubbell as Preeminent Lawyers for the years 1999 through the present.

Our History

In 1993, in recognition of the changing environment in the area of insurance defense, Roger H. Williams formed this law firm and practiced initially in Hudson, Ohio. Roger Williams brought with him nearly 15 years of jury trial and appellate experience and excellent rapport with clients, lawyers and judges alike.

The purpose of the founding of the firm was to provide efficient and quality representation to individuals, businesses and insurance carriers throughout the region and the nation. Our attorneys routinely travel throughout the State of Ohio, having access to the Ohio Turnpike, Interstate 480 and all other major interstates connecting cities across Northern Ohio.

In 2011, Roger Williams expanded the litigation practice to Westerville, Ohio to accommodate clients with litigation in Central and Southern Ohio—expanding the law firm’s practice to include all 88 counties of Ohio.

Individual Histories

In October of 1995, Louis R. Moliterno joined the firm, and has been with the firm on a continuous basis since that time. Lou Moliterno was promoted to Partner in 2001 and has enhanced his practice with jury trials, appellate arguments and client education seminars.

William F. Scully Jr. joined the firm as a partner in April of 1998, and brought to the firm at that time over 24 years of legal experience. Bill Scully’s trial resume includes matters in both state and federal courts, and experience with labor, insurance, tort and business litigation. He is now retired.

Kelly N. Grigsby joined the firm in the year 2000. Kelly Grigsby previously served as Judicial Staff Attorney for now retired Cuyahoga County Common Pleas Judge Lillian J. Greene. She was promoted to Partner in 2005, and contributes her experience to jury trials, legal education seminars, and appellate matters. She relocated to the Westerville office in 2011.

Anne M. Markowski joined the firm in April 2010, bringing more than 10 years of trial experience to this practice. She most recently worked as house counsel for Allstate Insurance Company, with impeccable trial results.

Ian R. Luschin joined the firm in 2006. Ian Luschin quickly gained recognition with clients and colleagues for his trial skills and legal writing.

In 2014, Holly Facer joined the firm, adding her talents to an already impressive group of litigators. In 2015, the firm expanded yet again, adding the skills of Bradley Dykes and Christina Williams, increasing the firm to eight attorneys.