WILLIAMS, MOLITERNO & SCULLY CO., L.P.A.,
is an AV-rated law firm concentrating on civil trial practice. We are experienced trial lawyers with a proven record at the courthouse.
Verdicts
LU JORDAN V. GIANT EAGLE SUPERMARKET, ET AL.
December 10, 2020 In Lu Jordan v. Giant Eagle Supermarket, et al., 2020-Ohio-109304, the Eighth District Court of Appeals affirmed the Trial Court’s decision granting Giant Eagle’s motion for judgment on the pleadings...
M.M. et al. v. M.F., et al.
In M.M. v. M.F., 2020-Ohio-5082, the Eighth District Court of Appeals affirmed summary judgment in Defendant M.F.’s favor on plaintiffs’ claims for negligent entrustment arising from a motor vehicle accident. The Court ruled that Plainti...
Daliah N. Beattie Maloney v. Christopher Smith
Summit County Court of Common Pleas, Judge Patricia Cosgrove, Jury Trial, Case No. CV2018-12-4968. Verdict February 14, 2020. Rear-end collision. Proximate cause & damages at issue. Cervical epidural injection at issue....
Darwin M. Dorsey v. Timothy J. Ebel, et al.
Cuyahoga County Court of Common Pleas, Judge Peter J. Corrigan, Jury Trial, Case No. CV-19-910535. Verdict February 12, 2020. Intersection action where both parties claimed to have the right-of-way. Defense verdict....
Rieger v. Giant Eagle, Inc.
The Ohio Supreme Court entered judgment in the case of Rieger v. Giant Eagle, Inc., 157 O.S.3rd 512, 2019-Ohio-3745. The Court ruled in favor of Defendant Giant Eagle reversing a civil jury trial held in October 2016 which resulted in a ...
Alysia Powers v. Diana Goodpasture
Summit County Court of Common Pleas. Judge John Haan, Jury Trial, Case No. CV2017-01-0309. Verdict June 21, 2019. Disputed liability. Minor chased by dog ran into the street where she was struck by a school van driven by Defendant....
Yinyan Guo v. Rebecca Delaney
Franklin County Court of Common Pleas, Magistrate Mark Petrucci, Jury Trial, Case No. 17CV007907. Verdict March 20, 2019. Intersection action where both parties claimed to have the right-of-way. Medicals included comminuted compound...
Robert Lee et. al. v. Karin Haas, et. al.,
Cuyahoga Common Pleas Court Case No. CV-15-850885. In April 2012, defendant Haas in the operation of her vehicle failed to maintain assured clear distance ahead, colliding with the rear of a vehicle operated by plaintiff Lee. The impact ...
Daniel Tasner, et al. v. Linda Lowe
Franklin County Common Pleas Court, Judge Charles Snyder, Case No. 12 CV 014703, Jury Verdict February 4, 2016....
James Forti, et al. v. Elizabeth Heydman
Franklin County Common Pleas Court, Judge Patrick Sheeran, Jury Trial by Magistrate Pamela Broer-Browing, Case No. 14 CV 01201, Verdict January 7, 2016....
Mary Ann Restifo v. Giant Eagle Inc.,
Cuyahoga Common Pleas Court Case No. CV-15-841679 (Judge Nancy Margaret Russo). Plaintiff Mary Restifo was a business invitee on the premises of the Biddulph Road Giant Eagle on or about Feb. 14, 2014. While walking through the floral de...
Funk v. Porozynski
Judge Paul Gallagher, Summit County Common Pleas Court – moderate impact motor vehicle accident with stipulated negligence; claimed injury was soft-tissue neck and back with treatment with Akron Square Chiropractic and Sam Ghoubrial,...
Wofford v. Moore
Garfield Heights Municipal Court, Judge Jennifer Weiler – rear-end, minimal impact motor vehicle accident with stipulated negligence; claimed injury was soft-tissue neck and back with treatment with Sam Ghoubrial M.D. and chiropractic;...
Jody Wright, et al. v Ashley Craig-Wilson, et al
Mahoning County Common Pleas Court Case No.: 13-CV-002611. This case arose from a stipulated negligence parking lot accident at Mr. Anthony’s Banquet Center, Boardman, on April 14, 2012. Photographs taken of the vehicles indicated a he...
Rosetta Leaper v. Siera Martin
Franklin County Common Pleas Court, Judge Kim J. Brown, Case No. 13 CV 011664, Bench Trial March 2, 2015....
Bailey v. Schultz
Summit County Common Pleas Court, Judge Allison McCarty – moderate-severe impact motor vehicle accident; negligence was disputed; primary claimed injury was deep laceration to the left infrapatellar tendon with surgical treatment;...
Christopher Bice v. GEICO
Jefferson County Common Pleas Court, Case No. 12-CIV-0214, Bench Trial Judge Christopher J. Regan....
Amy McClure v. Bonnie Stagers, et al
Licking County Common Pleas Court, Judge W. David Branstool, Case No. 13 CV 00103, Jury Trial July 22, 2014....
Kyle P. Newcomer v. Travis S. Meadows, et al.,
Morrow County Common Pleas Court, Judge Robert E. Hickson, Jr., Case No. 2012 CV 00022, Jury Verdict November 30, 2012....
Angell Carpenter v. Amy Metlesitz, et al.
Cuyahoga County Common Pleas Court, Judge William Coyne, Case No. CV 10 733478, Jury Verdict August 22, 2011 (post judgment appeal dismissed by Plaintiff’s counsel March 20, 2012)....
Verdicts
LU JORDAN V. GIANT EAGLE SUPERMARKET, ET AL.
December 10, 2020 In Lu Jordan v. Giant Eagle Supermarket, et al., 2020-Ohio-109304, the Eighth District Court of Appeals affirmed the Trial Court’s decision granting Giant Eagle’s motion for judgment on the pleadings...
M.M. et al. v. M.F., et al.
In M.M. v. M.F., 2020-Ohio-5082, the Eighth District Court of Appeals affirmed summary judgment in Defendant M.F.’s favor on plaintiffs’ claims for negligent entrustment arising from a motor vehicle accident. The Court ruled that Plainti...
Daliah N. Beattie Maloney v. Christopher Smith
Summit County Court of Common Pleas, Judge Patricia Cosgrove, Jury Trial, Case No. CV2018-12-4968. Verdict February 14, 2020. Rear-end collision. Proximate cause & damages at issue. Cervical epidural injection at issue....
Darwin M. Dorsey v. Timothy J. Ebel, et al.
Cuyahoga County Court of Common Pleas, Judge Peter J. Corrigan, Jury Trial, Case No. CV-19-910535. Verdict February 12, 2020. Intersection action where both parties claimed to have the right-of-way. Defense verdict....
Rieger v. Giant Eagle, Inc.
The Ohio Supreme Court entered judgment in the case of Rieger v. Giant Eagle, Inc., 157 O.S.3rd 512, 2019-Ohio-3745. The Court ruled in favor of Defendant Giant Eagle reversing a civil jury trial held in October 2016 which resulted in a ...
Alysia Powers v. Diana Goodpasture
Summit County Court of Common Pleas. Judge John Haan, Jury Trial, Case No. CV2017-01-0309. Verdict June 21, 2019. Disputed liability. Minor chased by dog ran into the street where she was struck by a school van driven by Defendant....
Yinyan Guo v. Rebecca Delaney
Franklin County Court of Common Pleas, Magistrate Mark Petrucci, Jury Trial, Case No. 17CV007907. Verdict March 20, 2019. Intersection action where both parties claimed to have the right-of-way. Medicals included comminuted compound...
Robert Lee et. al. v. Karin Haas, et. al.,
Cuyahoga Common Pleas Court Case No. CV-15-850885. In April 2012, defendant Haas in the operation of her vehicle failed to maintain assured clear distance ahead, colliding with the rear of a vehicle operated by plaintiff Lee. The impact ...
Daniel Tasner, et al. v. Linda Lowe
Franklin County Common Pleas Court, Judge Charles Snyder, Case No. 12 CV 014703, Jury Verdict February 4, 2016....
James Forti, et al. v. Elizabeth Heydman
Franklin County Common Pleas Court, Judge Patrick Sheeran, Jury Trial by Magistrate Pamela Broer-Browing, Case No. 14 CV 01201, Verdict January 7, 2016....
Mary Ann Restifo v. Giant Eagle Inc.,
Cuyahoga Common Pleas Court Case No. CV-15-841679 (Judge Nancy Margaret Russo). Plaintiff Mary Restifo was a business invitee on the premises of the Biddulph Road Giant Eagle on or about Feb. 14, 2014. While walking through the floral de...
Funk v. Porozynski
Judge Paul Gallagher, Summit County Common Pleas Court – moderate impact motor vehicle accident with stipulated negligence; claimed injury was soft-tissue neck and back with treatment with Akron Square Chiropractic and Sam Ghoubrial,...
Wofford v. Moore
Garfield Heights Municipal Court, Judge Jennifer Weiler – rear-end, minimal impact motor vehicle accident with stipulated negligence; claimed injury was soft-tissue neck and back with treatment with Sam Ghoubrial M.D. and chiropractic;...
Jody Wright, et al. v Ashley Craig-Wilson, et al
Mahoning County Common Pleas Court Case No.: 13-CV-002611. This case arose from a stipulated negligence parking lot accident at Mr. Anthony’s Banquet Center, Boardman, on April 14, 2012. Photographs taken of the vehicles indicated a he...
Rosetta Leaper v. Siera Martin
Franklin County Common Pleas Court, Judge Kim J. Brown, Case No. 13 CV 011664, Bench Trial March 2, 2015....
Bailey v. Schultz
Summit County Common Pleas Court, Judge Allison McCarty – moderate-severe impact motor vehicle accident; negligence was disputed; primary claimed injury was deep laceration to the left infrapatellar tendon with surgical treatment;...
Christopher Bice v. GEICO
Jefferson County Common Pleas Court, Case No. 12-CIV-0214, Bench Trial Judge Christopher J. Regan....
Amy McClure v. Bonnie Stagers, et al
Licking County Common Pleas Court, Judge W. David Branstool, Case No. 13 CV 00103, Jury Trial July 22, 2014....
Kyle P. Newcomer v. Travis S. Meadows, et al.,
Morrow County Common Pleas Court, Judge Robert E. Hickson, Jr., Case No. 2012 CV 00022, Jury Verdict November 30, 2012....
Angell Carpenter v. Amy Metlesitz, et al.
Cuyahoga County Common Pleas Court, Judge William Coyne, Case No. CV 10 733478, Jury Verdict August 22, 2011 (post judgment appeal dismissed by Plaintiff’s counsel March 20, 2012)....
OUR PHILOSOPHY
Our litigation philosophy is simple. The client, after consultation with the firm, chooses the lawyer in the firm best suited to handle each individual case. We investigate and evaluate cases rapidly and accurately. We attempt to resolve cases on a fair and equitable basis, as soon as possible, with minimal expense to our clients. We are not just litigators, but truly trial lawyers. If a fair and equitable settlement cannot be reached, we are ready, willing and able to take a matter to trial. Though we cannot guarantee a win in every case, we strive to provide our clients with the best representation available.
OUR PHILOSOPHY
Trial success.
Our recent verdicts demonstrate a willingness and ability to try cases.
Accurate and timely communication.
We quickly convey the information that our clients need to know.
Attention to detail.
The quality in our work comes through in our attention to the details.
Efficiency.
Our lean billings provide superior value to our clients.
Experience.
Our history of delivering quality results continues in every case we handle.
Knowledge.
We keep our knowledge base up-to-date by carefully studying ongoing changes in the complexities of the law.